Association between Ventilation Area and Thermal Comfort in Boarding School Dormitory Rooms

Isi Artikel Utama

Shaffana Kintani Azzahra
Junaidi Junaidi
Juanda Juanda

Abstrak

Ventilation plays a crucial role in creating thermal comfort, particularly in high-density residential environments such as Islamic boarding schools. Ventilation that does not meet established standards can lead to increased indoor temperature, excessive humidity, and poor air quality, thereby affecting occupants’ comfort and health. According to the standards of the Ministry of Health, the ideal ventilation area should be at least 10% of the floor area. This study aimed to analyze the relationship between ventilation area and thermal comfort in dormitory rooms of an Islamic boarding school. This study employed an analytic quantitative design with a cross-sectional approach. The sample consisted of 19 dormitory rooms and 262 female students from an Islamic boarding school in Banjar Regency, South Kalimantan. Data were collected through physical measurements (temperature, humidity, and air velocity) and a questionnaire assessing perceived thermal comfort. The measurement results showed that 94.7% of the dormitory rooms did not meet the ventilation area standard (≤10% of floor area). Among these rooms, 96.2% of occupants reported experiencing thermal discomfort. Meanwhile, in rooms that met the ventilation standard, all occupants (100%) also reported thermal discomfort. The chi-square test indicated a significant relationship between ventilation area and thermal comfort (p = 0.000; α = 0.05). These findings indicate that ventilation plays a role in thermal comfort, although other contributing factors should also be considered. Proper ventilation planning in accordance with established standards remains important as part of efforts to create a healthy residential environment in Islamic boarding schools.

Rincian Artikel

Bagian
policies

Referensi

Nyembwe JPKB, Munanga JK, Simões N, da Silva MG. Ventilation Strategies to Mitigate Air Pollution Impact on Hospital Professionals in Intensive Care Units in the Democratic Republic of Congo. Buildings 2024;14(7).

Bordin S, Weisböck-Erdheim R, Hummel S, Griener J, Hartl AJ, Dentel A. Long-Term Monitoring of Mechanical Ventilation and Window Airing in Classrooms: A Controlled Observational Study. Buildings 2025;15(17).

Park S, Hong C, Yun S, Cho Y. Development and Performance Evaluation Study of Window-Mounted Pressurized Ventilation Unit. In: 18th Conference of the International Society of Indoor Air Quality and Climate, INDOOR AIR 2024 - Conference Program and Proceedings. Incheon National University, Incheon, South Korea: International Society of Indoor Air Quality and Climate; 2024.

Vasile V, Iordache V, Radu VM. The influence of ventilation on indoor air quality in buildings with variable pollutant emissions. In: IOP Conference Series: Earth and Environmental Science. National Institute for Research and Development in Constructions, Urbanism and Sustainable Spatial Development, URBAN-INCERC, 266 Pantelimon Road, Bucharest, 021652, Romania: Institute of Physics; 2023.

Zhang X, Weerasuriya AU, Wang J, Li CY, Chen Z, Tse KT, et al. Cross-ventilation of a generic building with various configurations of external and internal openings. Build Environ 2022;207.

Rizzo K, Camilleri M, Gatt D, Yousif C. Optimising Mechanical Ventilation for Indoor Air Quality and Thermal Comfort in a Mediterranean School Building. Sustainability (Switzerland) 2024;16(2).

Alonso A, Suárez R, Llanos-Jiménez J, Muñoz-González CM. Students’ thermal and indoor air quality perception in secondary schools in a Mediterranean climate. Energy Build 2025;333.

Romero P, Miranda MT, Isidoro R, Arranz JI, Valero-Amaro V. Thermal Comfort and Sustainability in University Classrooms: A Study in Mediterranean Climate Zones. Applied Sciences (Switzerland) 2025;15(2).

Jastaneyah Z, Kamar HM, Hashmi A, Ghaleb FA, Al Garalleh H. The influence of zonal air supply on thermal comfort in a classroom located in a hot and humid environment: a case study from Jeddah—Saudi Arabia. Discover Sustainability 2024;5(1).

Mba EJ, Okeke FO, Ezema EC, Oforji PI, Ozigbo CA. Post Occupancy Evaluation of Ventilation Coefficient Desired for Thermal Comfort in Educational Facilities. Journal of Human, Earth, and Future 2023;4(1):88–102.

Toyinbo O. Indoor Environmental Quality, Pupils’ Health, and Academic Performance—A Literature Review. Buildings 2023;13(9).

Mba EJ, Okeke FO, Okoye U. Effects of wall openings on effective natural ventilation for thermal comfort in classrooms of primary schools in Enugu Metropolis, Nigeria. JP Journal of Heat and Mass Transfer 2021;22(2):269–304.

Fan X, Wargocki P, Silvestri A, Borkowski E, Schlueter A. Mediating effects of ventilation on the impacts of temperature on human comfort, health and cognitive performance: A living lab study. Build Environ 2025;285.

Zender-Świercz E, Telejko M, Galiszewska B, Starzomska M. Assessment of Thermal Comfort in Rooms Equipped with a Decentralised Façade Ventilation Unit. Energies (Basel) 2022;15(19).

Yin X, Muhieldeen MW, Razman R, Ee JYC, Chiong MC. The potential effects of window configuration and interior layout on natural ventilation buildings: A comprehensive review. Clean Eng Technol 2024;23.

Lee HC, Pan CY, Hsu HC. Indoor Air Quality and Improvement Strategies of Using Mechanical Ventilation in Confined Spaces. In: S.-J. C, S.-J. Y, A.D.K.-T. L, L.-W. J, S.D. P, editors. 2023 9th International Conference on Applied System Innovation, ICASI 2023. National Cheng Kung University, Department of Architecture, No. 1, Daxue Rd, East Dist., Tainan, 70101, Taiwan: Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers Inc.; 2023. page 261–3.

Molina-Aiz FD, Valera DL, López-Martínez A, Fatnassi H. Ventilation Models in Greenhouses. In: Protected Cultivation: Structural Design, Crop Management Modeling, and Automation. CIAMBITAL (Centro de Investigación en Agrosistemas Intensivos Mediterráneos y Biotecnología Agroalimentaria), University of Almería, Ctra. Sacramento s/n, Almería, Spain: Apple Academic Press; 2024. page 301–77.

Jiang Z, Kobayashi T, Sandberg M, Yamanaka T, Choi N, Sano K. Statistical Analysis Approach of Single-sided Ventilation Based on Particle Track Technique Using Large Eddy Simulation. In: R. O, editor. E3S Web of Conferences. Department of Architectural Engineering, Graduate School of Engineering, Osaka University, 2-1 Yamadaoka, Osaka, Suita, Japan: EDP Sciences; 2023.

Zhou J, Hua Y, Xiao Y, Ye C, Yang W. Analysis of ventilation efficiency and effective ventilation flow rate for wind-driven single-sided ventilation buildings. Aerosol Air Qual Res 2021;21(5).

Wellun Z, Yusoff WFM, Mohamed MF, Sulaiman MKAM, Rasani MRM. Effects of Single-Sided and Cross-Ventilated Sliding Glass Window Openings on the Indoor Environment of a Room in a Hot and Humid Climate. J Teknol 2022;84(6):107–14.

Prek M, Krese G, Lampret Ž. Incorporating cooling and ventilation effects into a single IEQ indicator. In: J. K, P. W, L. M, H. Z, I. N, S.-I. T, et al., editors. E3S Web of Conferences. University of Ljubljana, Faculty of Mechanical Engineering, Ljubljana, SI-1000, Slovenia: EDP Sciences; 2019.

Ahmed HS, Azeez NM. Indoor Carbon Dioxide Air Quality and Thermal Comfort in Primary School Classrooms of Maisan Province, Iraq. EnvironmentAsia 2023;16(3):94–103.

Wang H, Li G, Shi C. Predicting Sweat Rate of Chinese People under Moderate Activities Based on Experiments. In: Z. W, F. W, P. W, C. S, J. L, Y. Z, editors. Environmental Science and Engineering. School of Environment and Municipal Engineering, Qingdao University of Technology, No. 11 Fushun Road, Qingdao, 266033, China: Springer; 2020. page 47–56.

Zhang L, Sanake S. Social Welfare-Based Human Comfort Aggregation Model to Facilitate Healthy and Comfortable Indoor Environments. Journal of Architectural Engineering 2020;26(3).

Yang Y, Yu J, Lin B, Wang Z, Zhou F. Effects of metabolic rate on the human thermal responses: A large cross-sectional field survey. Build Environ 2025;270.

Kuga K, Wargocki P, Ito K. Impact of room temperature on human carbon dioxide emission rates at different physical activity levels. In: 17th International Conference on Indoor Air Quality and Climate, INDOOR AIR 2022. Kyushu University, Kasuga, Japan: International Society of Indoor Air Quality and Climate; 2022.

Ballerini V, Coccagna M, Bisi M, Volta A, Droghetti L, Rossi di Schio E, et al. The Role of Mechanical Ventilation in Indoor Air Quality in Schools: An Experimental Comprehensive Analysis. Buildings 2025;15(6).

Chow DHC. Indoor Environmental Quality: Thermal Comfort. In: Encyclopedia of Sustainable Technologies, Second Edition: Volumes 1-4. University of Liverpool, Liverpool, United Kingdom: Elsevier; 2024. page V2:283-V2:295.

Bueno AM, de Paula Xavier AA, Broday EE. Evaluating the connection between thermal comfort and productivity in buildings: A systematic literature review. Buildings 2021;11(6).

Kaushik A, Arif M, Tumula P, Ebohon OJ. Effect of thermal comfort on occupant productivity in office buildings: Response surface analysis. Build Environ 2020;180.

Paridokht F, Tabrizi A, Behzadi YK, Dehghan SF. Investigating Thermal Comfort and Ventilation in Schools: A Systematic Review. Journal of Health and Safety at Work 2025;15(3):687–723.

Sharma V, Dave T, Wani FA, Mathur J, Mathur S. Exploring the influence of indoor temperature on thermal comfort and performance. Sci Technol Built Environ 2025;31(4):466–83.

Chang L, Permana I, Wang F, Prasetyo BY. Improving Indoor Air Quality and Thermal Comfort Using a Total Heat Exchanger Ventilation System for an Office Building. Thermal Science 2024;28(6):4531–44.

Martins RS, Siqueira de Aquino G, Coelho Pagel É, Gouveia GLO de. Realistic designs of windows and doors as solutions to improve natural ventilation in hot-humid climates: a factorial design approach. Architectural Engineering and Design Management 2025;21(2):268–88.

Zhang X, Mishra A, Wargocki P. Carbon dioxide levels in buildings, cognitive performance, physiological responses, and health effects. In: 17th International Conference on Indoor Air Quality and Climate, INDOOR AIR 2022. Beijing Key Laboratory of Green Built Environment and Energy Efficient Technology, College of Architecture and Civil Engineering, Beijing University of Technology, Beijing, 100124, China: International Society of Indoor Air Quality and Climate; 2022.

Sulastri R. Studi kenyamanan termal ruang tidur santri di pesantren modern. J Arsitektur dan Lingkungan 18(1):44–52.